Imprès des de Indymedia Barcelona :
Independent Media Center
Anunci :: globalització neoliberal
Why your revolution is no liberation!
10 jun 2007
During the recent weeks and months a spirited debate developed in different German left wing newspapers and groups about the sense or non-sense, the perspectives and the means and goals of the mobilisation against the G8 summit. Different German and Austrian anti-fascist groups started a campaign to criticise a wrong analysis of capitalism widely spread in the anti-globalisation movement. In the context of this campaign several public discussions and lectures were held, a special webpage was set up but above all reader was published that contains a set of basic texts referring to this problem. This reader is available in German and English and will soon also be published in French in order to spread the debate also across other countries. Check it out:
With this reader, we want to take a stand against the currently predominating analyses, of the anti-globalisation movement, which, articulating themselves as in the broadest sense left-wing and anticapitalist, constantly boisterously trumpet their opinion, that another world was possible. We have serious doubts that this âotherâ? world, was going to be of a better constitution than the current one. This anti-globalisation movement is of course not at all marginalised, but is enjoying broad sympathy, which reaches from the âbourgeois leftâ? right to the so-called centre of society and which is even shared by Neo-Nazis

The anti-globalisation movement is-as its protagonists certainly emphasise when facing criticism-a heterogenous movement, in which many groups and individuals have agreed to a minimum consensus. In the case of the activities against this yearâs G8-summit this consensus will consist of the participating heads of government being evil, whereas demonstrators and activists on the other side of the fence are âgoodâ?. Within the last couple of years, another consensus has-explicitly and implicitly-been agreed on: An antagonism toward the USA and Israel, as well as a structurally anti-Semitic criticism of capitalism.

The closing statement of the world social forum of Porto Alegre expressed the forum`s solidarity with the âPalestinian peopleâ? - not a word about suicide bombings or islamic anti- Semitism. The European Social Forum in Paris willingly offered a platform to the islamist and anti-semite Tariq Ramadan, whilst activists, that criticised the anti-Semitism of the No-Globals in a Flyer, were attacked and expelled from the forum. At an event during the EU-Summit in Copenhagen the Danish group âGlobal Rootsâ? demanded a boycott of Israel stewards wore shirts with the slogan âBurn Israel Burnâ? on them. During an ATTAC meeting in Germany the Italian globalisation critic Alfonso de Vito compared Israels policy toward the Palestinians with the eviction of the Warsaw Ghetto. Noam Chomsky who canâ t detect anti-Semitism in Robert Faurrissons statement that the holocaust was a Zionist lie authored a manifesto in summer 2006 which declares Israel guilty of the Hisbollahs attack on Israels North because it was aiming to liquidate the Palestinian state. This silly writ which not only ignores the fact that there is no Palestinian state but also turns a blind eye to Israels withdrawal from the Gaza strip and the subsequent terror offensive of the Palestinians was promptly signed by other idols of the anti-globalisation movement: Naomi Klein, Jose Sarango, Arundhati Roy (amongst others).The latter was recently only notable by a completely amiss analysis of capitalism in which globalisation - equated with imperialism - is understood as a conspiracy of âmen in suitsâ?(Americans of course), who âtrek the world like locustsâ?. Not forgetting the messias and head-of-state of the No-Globals, Hugo Chavez, close ally of the Iranian mullah regime which is currently sedously working on the nuclear destruction of Israel and which flaunts its president as the international figurehead of an extermination-anti-Semitism.

Why the hatred for Israel and the Jews? After every attack on a synagogue or another Jewish institution Israels allegedly disproportional military policy is at least considered as the reason for the attack. No assault on a mosque or an African immigrant in Europe has ever been justified with a reference to the policy of Muslim or African states. Why the personalisation of the circumstances of capital? It should be known since Marx that capitalism is not an event staged by handful of âmen in suitsâ? but a total social condition. With this cognizance this reader wants to contribute to the formulation of a radical criticism.

This work licensed under a
Creative Commons license


Re: Why your revolution is no liberation!
10 jun 2007
Ciero que hay antisemitismo en muchos sitios, pero este texto tiene una argumentación patética, vacía y casi demagógica.
Y por otro parte, cualquier religión organizada es una amenaza a la libertad individual.
Re: Why your revolution is no liberation!
10 jun 2007
Aquests són els anti_deutsch, ignorants dogmàtics que per una operació tremendament simplista, per reacció a l'antisemitisme (que seria més correcte anomenar antijudaisme, doncs els àrabs també són semites) es posicionen incondicionalment i acrítica a favor d'Israel i consegüentment amb els EEUU i les seves polítiques assassines. Si diuen que en les crítiques anti-israelianes no hi han mencions als atacs terroristes, en aquest panflet tampoc es veuen moltes referències a la política sistemàticament criminal d'Israel.
Re: Why your revolution is no liberation!
11 jun 2007
Me hace gracia esta historia. por 50 decadas los palestinos tiraban piedras y morian, pero no tenian derecho a nada. Ahora se defienden con las armas y son solo terroristas.
Un pueblo que se defiende de una ocupacion militar no es terrorismo.
Antialemanes capitalistas y imperialistas.
Viva la palestina
Muerte al imperialismo (americano,israeli,spain,etc)
Re: Why your revolution is no liberation!
11 jun 2007
Com pot ser que alguns moviments d'esquerres alemanys defensen l'Estat racista, invasor i assassí d'Israel ?
Aixó ès l'incoherència total.
Palestina lliure i deixeu-vos de victimisme pro-sionista!